Yesterday’s solutions

IF THE observance of Indian Arrival Day today sends us any message at all, it could hardly be a call for unalloyed rejoicing. There can be no doubt, of course, about the tremendous contribution which the East Indian community has made to the all-round development of our country; their members can be proud of it and the rest of the nation should be glad to recognise it. But the national holiday, intended to commemorate the arrival of this vital section of our population 158 years ago, finds us in a situation where, instead of seeking to advance the level of harmony and tolerance we have achieved as a multi-ethnic society, some influential voices are still intent on sowing the seeds of discord by their continuing emphasis on discrimination, alienation, victimisation and their depiction of East Indians as a suppressed community of second class citizens.

What our nation and its citizens need now is a greater feeling of love, respect and appreciation for one another. But that idea is nothing original. We remember one particular voice, at a certain time, proclaiming the truth that our country will only achieve its full potential when the two major ethnic groups come together in a spirit of unity. An obvious observation, but was it only lip service? That consummation, indeed the encouragement of efforts to achieve it, should, in our view, be part of the central message of today’s observance.

More than a century and a half after the freeing of African slaves and the importation of Indians to replace them on the colonial sugar plantations, Trinidad and Tobago is still a society in transition, still seeking its true identity. Maybe we will never find it, as the evolutionary process of integrating so much diversity, so much plurality, so many different traditions, seems a long and difficult one indeed. But, as history and fate would have it, that is our destiny; whatever our origins might be, we are “doomed” to share these two small islands as one society, one aspiring nation.

As we travel that road, willy nilly, the voices of division and dissension and protest and dislocation can only serve us ill. They are yesterday’s voices, offering yesterday’s stale solutions. They can only lead to a turning back of the clock. Let us, on this special day, recognise that our society has made remarkable strides, thanks in part to the industry of the East Indian community. And the results and benefits of their success are there for all to see. But we are still a long way from achieving the kind of development that would wipe out poverty and deprivation from our land and the kind of social unity that would mould us closer to true nationhood. Whatever the problems may be in this regard, whatever the seemingly insurmountable barriers that appear in our way, the fact is, we can only hope to progress by approaching them honestly and constructively, on the basis of demonstrable truth and mutual good will, and always by an unwavering commitment to the principle stated in our anthem, that here every creed and race must find an equal place.

Ours is an open society grappling with the challenges of a rapidly changing world. The opportunities for individual, group and corporate growth and achievement are open to all. We have a free and democratic foundation on which to build. We have national institutions that have served us well. We are free to agitate for changes that would improve our effectiveness and ensure the equity of our dealing. We have an intelligent society that should know the uselessness of divisive agitators, offering yesterday’s solutions.

UNITY LEADS TO PROSPERITY

Prime Minister Mr Patrick Manning has sent the following Message to the National Community on the occasion of Indian Arrival Day 2003 which we celebrate today:


ON behalf of the Government of People of the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago, I wish to extend greetings to the National Community as we celebrate Indian Arrival Day, 2003.

It is now 158 years since the arrival of the first group of East Indian immigrants aboard the Fatel Al Razak. The subsequent evolution of the East Indian community in Trinidad and Tobago has proven to be a constructive engagement. Our people of East Indian descent continue to make an invaluable contribution to the development of our nation, and we are grateful for the preservation and passing on of various aspects of their traditions, cultural norms and institutions. Appreciably, too, as with other groups among us, there have been many positive adjustments and adaptations, so much so that after more than one and one half centuries our East Indian fellow citizens are as integrated as any other into all aspects of our national life. It is indeed remarkable and to be commended therefore, the extent to which East Indians in Trinidad and Tobago have joined other groups, largely of immigrant background themselves, in working out a model plural society in which for the most part our institutions are increasingly being shared and relations are growing more and more connected and positively inextricable.

Today, rare is the citizen who does not feel or see himself or herself as part of our nation. This is not to say that there are no challenges. Notwithstanding that these are common to groups living in plural societies, the people of Trinidad and Tobago have long been exceptional and exemplary in the manner in which we have been forging before the world one nation out of the disparate social elements bequeathed by our colonial experience. It is therefore to the credit of all in our small but great nation that we continue to evolve as a society which is becoming progressively neutral regarding gender, class, race, religion and the like, and which has been making it possible for all to realise their highest aspirations and ambitions. Even so, it still remains our challenge to build further in this regard. The evidence is that we can, as we have already been doing so. It is imperative that we are to intensify our efforts as we can ill-afford to do otherwise. For, as a nation, the greatest discredit and disservice to which we can subject ourselves is to foster, either as individuals or groups within our society, thoughts, habits or actions that can separate or divide us as a nation. Extremism and fundamentalism are to be avoided in every form, including those that will entreat us to see race or a particular differentiation as the basis behind every action, issue or development.

The people of our beloved country have long been more united than this and we can only sell ourselves short with any such approach, having already progressed far beyond that stage. After so many years of integration and interaction following our various arrivals we are now at that point where our ethnic diversity, for example, should be cherished for the colour, quality, character, resilience and strength that it can and has provided for our nation. Let us therefore celebrate Indian Arrival Day this year as a nation in which all our people have truly come to terms with the fact of our diversity. Let us show ourselves as a nation fully appreciative of the merits of our cosmopolitan makeup and determined to demonstrate to the world that groups of different backgrounds can both live together and progress in peace and harmony, on the basis of genuine understanding, appreciation and love and respect for each other. Does not the Ramayana exhort us as follows?“Jahaa sumatee tahaa sampatee nana.” “Through unity, prosperity and progress flourishes unceasingly.”

Just differently-abled

THE EDITOR: It is with a sad feeling I write this letter, on reading that a group of police officers manhandled a group of disabled persons on Monday (May 26) night outside the National Flour Mills compound where the disabled have set up camp.

According to Mr George Daniel, chairman of the Trinidad and Tobago for the chapter of the Disabled Persons’ International, it came as quite a shock to himself and his membership. According to the news story a group of police officers ascended on the disabled men, roughed them up, to the point of injury, hurled harsh words and unsavoury comments at them; how sad! These disabled citizens are also citizens of Trinidad and Tobago, and they too have choices and decisions to make according to their future. They (the disabled) are not asking the government for handouts, but they want an equal share of the national pie. Being disabled does not make you or one less human, they are differently-abled. Citizens should show their support, by standing with them and joining in their cause. There is hardly any legislation, or even law to incorporate them into the “normal” stream of society, all they are asking for is to be recognised by the relevant authorities to meet their demands and needs.

Allow me to share an experience (a story) of a friend who is disabled, but beat the odds to become a successful businessman. Michael (not his real name) came from a poor and underprivileged family. During his formative years he was adopted and lived in foster homes. At the orphanage he excelled, he became a paraplegic on account of a fall in his early years. At the home he did his exams, attended a junior-secondary school, where he learned a trade, and became good at what he did. At senior secondary he did business administration. After leaving secondary school he did private studies on his own, and mastered in business. Today (May 2003) he owns his own business; he did not allow his physical challenges to deter him from getting ahead. Although he had to struggle all through his life, he was determined to be a success and he became a success. What are the relevant authorities doing to help the disabled in our country? I am sad, but as citizens we must show our support to the handicapped in our society.

KEN SMITH
Woodbrook

Small wage for risking life

THE EDITOR: It seems that despite the increase in deaths of security guards, the government still hasn’t addressed the wage situation, or have they? Will there ever be fair wages for underpaid security personnel? Or will we continue to be disrespected and ignored by the government and businesses that we protect and risk our lives for?

People consider security to be one of the lowest occupations in the country and so they disrespect us this way. In truth and in fact, some security “guards” are intelligent individuals who seek an honest dollar because there are not enough jobs out there for people, so I am asking the population to respect the security industry and its personnel for the risk they perform for your welfare and personal comfort.


JUNIOR ROBERTS
Belmont

Captain, this plane not flying — fast track it…

THE EDITOR: Whilst there is much speculation on the part of certain elements of the media as to the “honesty” of the BWEE management — a question first insinuated by PM Manning when he postulated as to whether these gentlemen were being completely up front in their dealings with him — his official stance from the start of the crisis has been one of no crisis — “we shall deal with it in our own good time and howsoever it pleases me.” That crisis status is unimportant and Mr Manning’s perceptions should be evident from the medical impasse (sorry, the first evidence of non acknowledgment of “crisis” and effect thereof to any but himself and Party was in fact the ten-months impasse period after 24/12/01).

Although hedging on the Bwee issue, the PM has been very open and quick to communicate to partner Gonsalves and Co his commitment to keeping LIAT going and the necessity for a regional, if not international, airline. With these commitments in mind it might not be unhelpful if Bwee were to go “belly up” (along with the 40 percent or more of Government owned stock in same) and no longer constitute a spoke in the wheel, so to speak. That this shareholding is yours, mine and ours (investment of taxpayers hard earned money) should be of prime importance. He is the captain, if not of the ship of state, at least the architect of the current state of ship. He will decide. (I hope he remembers that a captain does not abandon a sinking ship). He might also do well to recall that in 1970 BWIA had an aircraft waiting on the tarmac manned for instant departure, awaiting only the arrival of Williams and his entourage at a moment’s notice — no foreign airline is going to offer that service. What do you think that cost BWIA? The tarnishing of Bwee’s reputation (by extension that of TT and all Trinis to the bone is another factor which he does not appear to have taken into consideration nor the long term effect upon the non-Trini travelling public of the spectacle of seizure for debts owed).

This entire matter brings to mind the Airport Enquiry and the opprobrium for “fast tracking” methods utilised. This is one occasion upon which a prayerful PM would be well advised to adopt this UNC approach. Fast tracking would appear to have been utilised in the formation of CEPEP and the transformation of prime agricultural land at St Joseph farm into housing plots, so the concept is not altogether foreign to Mr Manning’s administration. This time, however, fast tracking a Bwee resolution will redound to the benefit of each and every citizen of TT — who are all stakeholders in the national airline. Ask any Trini to the bone, I think you will find that thus far they have all been very proud of their airline, just as they are proud of their Red House.


VIRGINIA VERITY
Port-of-Spain

OUR SEASONAL DILEMMAS

In this changing land of ours tears are shed in vain
Sufferers will tell you, “Boy ah goin’ insane.”


Let’s look at our weather, it’s either wet or dry
today was such a scorcher, few clouds were in the sky.


We see daily hardships – there’s fire on the hills,
Lives and homes engulfed by flames, and more “no water” thrills.


So WASA keeps repeating, “Dams are very low”
If water’s coming out your tap, it’s definitely slow.


It seems our sharp leaders have missed the urgency
Rain never fails to save our necks, is their philosophy.


But with the months of water, come a different
kind of pain
Landslides and flooding both abound —
daily incessant rain.


Compounding those disasters, is raping of the land
Debris heaps of every form give doom a helping hand.


If you live in Central, you must know how to swim
For rivers gushing through your house, is considered very grim.


Folks who live on mountains, have other
 thoughts in mind
With fears of slipping down the hill, how
can they unwind?
Maybe there’ll be an answer — maybe one day we’ll see,
That plans for such disasters prevail in TT.

DEXTER J RIGSBY
Mt Lambert

Show respect for the library, it’s not a place to lime

THE EDITOR: Certain unruly secondary school students should be banned from the new library since they are badly behaved and show no respect for authority at this institution. Those interested in studying or borrowing books must be supplied with a certificate of good character from their school principal and after he/she consults with their form teachers. This is the only way they should be allowed to enter the doors of the library.

From the way certain pupils behave on the street it could be seen that they are not interested in an education but continue to waste their school days. It is a trend with certain students not to study, but only go to school to lime, going through the motions while at times only continue to disturb other students who want to be successful in their education. There are certain pupils who go to school with one purpose, and that is to make sure of obtaining a proper education with the thought of being doctor, a lawyer or some other profession, but there are those who would waste their time, and would eventually turn out to be hoodlums living a life of crime. When certain students go to the library to use it as a liming spot, and behave badly it reflects on the school which they attend.

The library is a place to be respected. It is not a place to have dates with the school girls who should show more respect for themselves and should only think of their education. There are those with another aim, and that is to be fully educated while gaining full passes which would entitle them to scholarships so they can study to be professionals in whatever field they choose. Many of these pupils top the country in these exams which give them the opportunity to further their education at a university. When we read of students who lime and where unruly behaviour is the norm, and there are frequent fights it is appalling to hear of these malpractices by these unruly students, I believe when this happens the security of the library should hold these students and get in touch with their parents because in many instances their parents are not aware of how badly their children behave when they are not in their persence. The pupils who are well behaved and are serious in their studies must be accepted at the library, but those who believe that the library is a place to lime must be banned from this institution but will only be accepted with a certificate of good character from their school principal.

HORACE DESORMEAUX
Maraval

La Horquetta says thanks to sponsors

THE EDITOR: It is not very often people say thank you, or show gratitude, when good deeds are done.

 on this note the La Horquetta Community Council takes this opportunity to say “Thanks” to the many sponsors who made our Eleventh Annual Sports and Family Day a success on Easter Sunday April 20, 2003. We therefore express our thanks and gratitude to the following persons and organisations; The Minister of Legal Affairs, – Mrs Camille Robinson-Regis; Chairman, Tunapuna/Piarco Regional Corporation; Mayor of Arima His Worship Mr Elvin Edwards; President of the Maxi Taxi Association Mr Costa George; Barbara Bourne; SS Rescue Mart — Ms Onica Mayers; Eric Dennis Bar (Arima); Board of Management — La Horquetta Regional Complex; Hamburger Grill (La Horquetta); Jesus Ministries; La Horquetta Improvement Committee; Chico’s, Mini Mart; Trinidad and Tobago Fire Services Youth Band; All members of the La Horquetta Community Council; Regional Manager — URP Arima; Coordinator Arouca South. These persons answered our calls for sponsorship of this event and we are very grateful for their assistance, we look forward to their support in our future endeavours.

JACQUELINE SHORTT
Secretary
La Horquetta Community Council

Superficial gestures not helping to improve people’s lives

THE EDITOR: On Friday May 16, I was visiting the school on the compound of one of the government-run children’s homes. I was in the Principal’s office upstairs, talking to the Principal and a teacher, when I shifted my stance slightly and my shoe heel went right through a rotten floorboard. As I tugged with both hands to haul it back out, while the teacher looked around for a patch of new floorboards where I could stand more safely, I thought to myself, Total Quality nation? Total Bloody Nonsense!!!

I have no faith at all in Vision 2020, unless part of its plan is a plan to remove the political leaders in both government and opposition and replace them with people who can think past the next opinion pool. The greatest obstacle for us in achieving total quality, anything is the fact that those governing us have not the slightest idea of what is priority or what is even real. Take a look at the facts: increasing crime among youth, increasing violence, deterioration of schools, collapse of the health system, unequal rights for the disabled, cancer patients holding barbecues to pay for medication and injections, burning of the hills every dry season, communities which have never had paved roads, reliable water supply, electricity or telephone service.

Take a look at the response: CEPEP (absolutely, certainly, definitely not the same as DEWD, sorry, LIDP, sorry, BURP, sorry URP), one hundred Cuban doctors, buying buildings downtown, moving Parliament, the University of Trinidad in Wallerfield. Do you see any connection to what we actually need? I don’t. I don’t see improved and expanded social services, rehabilitation centres specifically for young people, a complete rethinking of the education system based on the most recent research and best practice in education, professional mental health services made available to all communities, community development, improvement of the infrastructure (as opposed to pouring pitch on the roads every election), proper restructuring and reorganisation of the health system (and I do not mean RHAs) adequately funded and staffed children’s homes with all the required special needs resources at their disposal. In other words, all I see are grand superficial gestures, but I don’t see services for people or measures taken to improve the standard of people’s daily lives.

It is incredible to me that successive governments have complacently presided over the continued decline of so many or our essential services without ever thinking that something should be done to halt the slide. But I had to believe it as I hauled my shoe out of that splintered floor and thanked God that it was me and not a child. Until recently, I had despaired of ever making those in authority understand the issues. That is why I am so glad at what has happened with the National Library. With all the difficulties which young people have to face, those in power saw fit to give them a brand new library to solve their problems. Did they think it would solve the violence, the crime, the dysfunction in their homes? Well, the young people have certainly used it to draw attention to their reality. They have taken a shameless public relations exercise and converted it into a national stage on which they show us what they have to deal with — vandalism, violence, sexual abuse, learning problems, lack of discipline and structure in their environment. The lesson is clear. The only message which gets through to the powers that be is public mayhem — vandalism, crime, violence, delinquency. Unless we rock their little world of illusion, we do not exist. And that is the total quality of the governance we have brought upon our heads.


KAREN MOORE
Champs Fleurs

Windies chase more one-day success

ST GEORGE’S: Australia are looking for a return to winning ways after their 21-match streak came to an end in Trinidad. One loss in 22 matches is a record to make any captain proud, but for Aussie skipper Ricky Ponting his team is only as good as their last match.

The visitors have already secured the one-day series, but hope to go out on a high in the two remaining games, both at the National Stadium. “The loss was a wake-up for us,” Ponting said after the West Indies won by 67 runs last Sunday. “If we don’t play at our best then you can be beaten and that’s what happened. “We’ve had a few days off before (today’s) game so we’ve had plenty of time to freshen up and make sure we’re a better team. I’m disappointed it ended — it would have been nice to continue it a bit longer — but I’m very proud of how we’ve done it and how we’ve gone about it.”

Aussie fast bowler Brett Lee sent the camp into a panic during Wednesday’s net session when he was struck on the back of the head, suffering mild concussion. Australia are also yet to make decisions on the fitness of Michael Bevan and Glenn McGrath, both of whom suffered groin strains on Sunday. But experienced middle-order batsman Darren Lehmann is expected to have fully recovered from a calf strain. There is an air of expectancy in Grenada for the two matches with schools being given a day off and employers asked to give leave to every worker who has a match ticket.

No Grenadian has played an international game at Grenada’s National Stadium since it was opened four years ago.  But locals will have to wait until Sunday at least to see young opener Devon Smith, who will serve as 12th man for today’s match. And young all-rounder Ryan Hurley, who injured his shoulder in taking a spectacular catch to dismiss Jimmy Maher in Trinidad, was replaced by fast bowler Vasbert Drakes.


Teams : WEST INDIES (from): Chris Gayle, Wavell Hinds, Ramnaresh Sarwan, Brian Lara (capt), Marlon Samuels, Ricardo Powell, Ridley Jacobs, David Bernard, Vasbert Drakes, Mervyn Dillon, Corey Collymore.
AUSTRALIA (from): Matthew Hayden, Adam Gilchrist, Ricky Ponting (capt), Darren Lehmann, Michael Clarke, Andrew Symonds, Ian Harvey, Brad Hogg, Andy Bichel, Nathan Hauritz, Brett Lee, Jason Gillespie.