Silver fox and cubs obstruct justice

THE EDITOR: After years of trying to project themselves as a national party, they build their whole parliamentary agenda round Caroni Ltd, pushing all other critical national interests to the background. This is a throwback to the 1970s when their predecessors were sarcastically referred to as a sugar cane party.

After years of preaching national unity to attract more Africans to the party, the major basis on which they discuss the Caroni Ltd issue is race. They are supporting efforts to block the Caroni VSEP when thousands of sugar workers, their supporters, eagerly want the VSEP. They demand debate on Caroni Ltd but when the government calls their bluff, they are caught with their proverbial pants down. The majority of victims of kidnapping are Indians. This means that statistically it is likely that these are mainly UNC supporters. Yet they refuse to support the Kidnapping Bill that is meant to get tough on kidnappers. They do not seem to mind that their supporters get kidnapped as long as the PNM looks bad.

The Silver Fox has run out of ideas. He is repeating the same 1960s lines, referring to second class citizens, discrimination and alienation: “I’d rather die than live like a second class citizen in my own country.” Yawn. During the 18-18 deadlock they shut down the parliament by obstructing the election of a Speaker. In the process they made a mockery of the parliament. For this obstruction, they are now warming the benches in the wilderness of the opposition. Still, in this new parliament they are obstructing again, threatening to support any legislation that needs their support, national interest or no national interest. They reneged on the Crowne Plaza Accord to force elections. They got elections, which they lost. Yet they are again reneging on another agreement — support for the Police Reform Bill. Some people never learn.

While they rant and rave about Caroni Ltd and make silly allegations about government spying, they fail to recognise that the single biggest fear among citizens is crime, particularly kidnapping. One of these days the man selling nuts on the highway may be kidnapped for ransom. I do not know of anyone who is not afraid of being kidnapped. But the UNC apparently lives on Mars so they aggressively pursue other issues instead of kidnapping. They repeatedly seek to raise trivial issues as matters of urgent public importance in parliament like the boy who cried wolf. So when there is really an urgent matter, they will run out of steam and have little effect.


PETER JAGROOP
Edinburgh Village
Chaguanas

Time to rally again as West Indies plays Australia

THE EDITOR: Mr Brian Charles Lara has resumed the captaincy of the senior West Indies team. This is Mr Lara’s second time as captain of the team. In 1998, Brian Lara was given the post to captain the West Indies team. This captaincy did not prove to be a successful one, they even suffered a “white wash” against South Africa during his captaincy term.

In March 2003, an announcement was made by the West Indies Cricket Board, he is to lead the team once more, and the vice captain is Mr Ramnaresh Sarwan. What will be our chances when the visiting and world champs Australia visit later this month? As Trinidadians and Tobagonians we must support Brian Charles Lara, and rally around the West Indies in their upcoming series. As a West Indian I have been saddened by the performance of the team, and in the recent past I have not been following any of the series, especially the World series.

The performance of the West Indies team is very disappointing, seeing in the 1970’s and 1980s the West Indies team was the number one cricket team in the world, allow me to mention names such as Clive Lloyd, Vivian Richards, the late Sir Learie Constantine, Derek Murray, Larry Gomes, such greats took the West Indies to their victorious wins. Caribbean, West Indian crowds took pleasure, delight in supporting their fellow-men back them; anyway enough said about the past. Wishing the West Indies team all the best in the upcoming matches against Australia and Sri Lanka.


KEN  SMITH
Woodbrook

A foreign national team is not a ‘team’

THE EDITOR: While listening an observing closely at the recently concluded Gold Cup qualifiers, I couldn’t help but wonder what was happening to our national team. Prior to the results of the game against Cuba, I was appalled by my observations. The powers to be seem unable to accurately visualise or fully comprehend that football in TT is slowly deteriorating. This manner of negligence is being  displayed by our top sportsmen and leaders in this field, which in my opinion is totally unacceptable.

Could you imagine, a national team comprised mainly of “so called” foreign based professional players with a few selected locals? This process should be reserved. We have lost all direction and focus. We need to give our local players the exposure and the opportunity to develop their skills and ability in this field. Yes coach, we do want to gain our best “team,” not just individuals. The kind of message being sent to our young and aspiring footballers is, in order to qualify for the national team, one must be foreign based. This type of bias action and opinion, could only destroy and discourage the minds, spirit and potential of our young and zealous sportsmen, while impacting negatively on our leaders in this field.

I reiterate and emphasise that football is a team sport comprised of individuals. Not an individual sport. We need to recruit team players with an inordinate desire to work harmoniously and co-exist with each other; players who possess that commitment, passion and drive towards achieving the ultimate goal for their team and their country. We don’t need players who are of the opinion that they are stars or professionals and are unable to commit to the team because they are foreigners and over confident. This could only hurt the future of the team.

It is disappointing to note that year after year we continue to produce a national team that is not mentally or physically ready to achieve winning results. A tournament of such calibre and stature as the Gold Cup, and here we are, only a couple of weeks before the tournament commences, and we choose to recruit ten foreign based players and expect them to perform successfully as a team, while our talented local players fall to the side. This is such a shame.

In addition, we tend to focus more on playing amongst ourselves or mediocre teams, which is not the style and level of football played in tournaments. We need to challenge our players and give them the exposure to play with European and South American teams in order for them to develop physically and mentally as professionals. In my humble opinion, this national foreign based team was a big mistake coach Najar. It is time for us to give our locally based, professional players much more credit and recognition, as well as improved sporting facilities. For it is only then are we able to achieve maximum effort from all and move forward as a team toward success.


LENO  FORDE
Arima

Respect starts at the top

THE EDITOR: The Ministry of Education should be lauded for organising programmes to help stem the tide of indiscipline and violence in the nation’s schools. However, serious attempts must also be made to ensure that discipline begins at the top.

There is no way we can have peace in our schools if administrators fail to provide accountability, transparency and exemplary behaviour to their own staff and students. Some principals raise funds in their schools and refuse to provide proper financial accountability to their staff. The time has come for the Education Ministry to insist that all administrators account for school funds. Some of them refuse to do so, which is a serious act of indiscipline.

I wish to point out that if the head of an institution is not respected by staff, students and parents, there is no way he/she can be an effective leader. Principals and teachers who drink excessively and go to classes turn off students. These young people also have little or no respect for those who curse, smoke and abuse them on the school compound and then turn around and tell them how they should behave. It is known that certain teachers and principals need urgent help with their substance abuse problems, so it’s difficult to ask them to help keep our children sober.

I wish to point out that many student councils have their work cut out for them by autocratic administrators who really don’t want their students to address issues that may expose them in a negative way. This is so because some principals do not want bad publicity for their school nor do they wish to the public to know the wrongs they commit. The Education Ministry needs to appoint people to visit our schools and listen to the grievances of not only principals, but teachers and students as well. The appointed people must not be individuals who are part of the problem or part of the cover-up. The Ministry should ensure that they are fair and willing to assist all the stakeholders. We must not make believe that students are the only ones contributing to indiscipline and violence in schools.

Many children, who can be helped with the proper approach and counselling, are instead suspended. This contributes to further indiscipline and violence. Some principals take the easy way out by suspending students as soon as they commit an offence. On numerous occasions my colleagues and I have had to help suspended students who we believe should have remained in school. A student on suspension must be sent to a rehabilitative centre, otherwise we will be adding to the indiscipline and violence in society.

The shortage of male teachers in the classroom is a major reason for some of the problems in schools. There are co-ed schools where the principal, vice principal and those acting for them when they are absent, are all women. This cannot be an ideal situation, so we call on the Education Ministry to address this imbalance in our schools. I agree with Fr Gerry Pantin that teachers must be selected in our schools not only for their academic qualifications but also for their loving and caring attitude. The future teachers must be all trained to deal with aggressive students. In that way, we will have no need to constantly blame a shortage of counsellors for indiscipline and violence in schools.

HARRACK  BALRAMSINGH
La Romain

Letter to the Minister of Health

THE EDITOR: A nation’s health is its wealth. The people who work in health need to be having some wealth, security and respect granted unto them.

New health risks added to the already long list of diseases out here are putting hospital attendants and other medical staff at risk everyday. The hospital attendant is at the forefront of the battle for a healthier nation and need re-classification now. I am calling on the Minister of Health, PSA, CPO to deal with this matter urgently. This group of well-trained medical officers is leaving the shores of this country. Incentive and a training structure are necessary now to keep these good medical officers.

The introduction of the RHA health has seen its worst period in the history of this nation with reported misuse of public funds and high salaries for people who are not trained hospital administrators, who dont even know that there are different  wheelchairs and trolleys for different departments in a hospital. The hospital attendants cannot function in the best interest of health and safety because of these square pegs in round holes. Every piece of equipment has a warranty and at present all the trolleys and wheelchairs need to be replaced at our nation’s institutions, this is no time to talk cost here, now is the word Minister Colm Imbert. Kill the RHA we have paid our debt, look at the suffering taking place, take back control, Ministry of Health.


A WHEELER
Belmont

Kicksin’ in Senate?

WHILE it is accepted that debates in Parliament are not tea parties and they should provide some leeway for the cut and thrust of the political arena, it is important not to allow them to degenerate into fish markets where members lose respect for time-honoured traditions, the tenets of proper debate, the inviolability of Standing Orders, the authority of the Chair and the dignity of the national forum itself. It is our view, in fact, that Parliament and its members have a general responsibility for setting standards and examples of good conduct for the rest of the country, particularly our young people, and when members of either house continually misbehave they may be contributing seriously to the growing indiscipline in the society.

Having said all that, however, we must accept the reality that Parliament is the central arena of our adversarial political system and will always be subject to the attacks of members seeking to gain some advantage against the other side, whether guided by the rules or not. An argument may also be made that it should be allowed to reflect the robustness of our culture. So while we cannot fault President of the Senate Dr Linda Baboolal for reading the riot act on Tuesday in order to deal with what she described as the growing “unruly and disrespectful” behaviour of Senators we should, at the same time, remind her of the essential confrontational nature of the national forum and that it would be foolhardy for her to expect gentlemanly behaviour from members at all times.

Issuing warnings may be useful, but it is her job to maintain order and deal with breaches as they arise. It may seem unfortunate that the President should have to resort to such strict warnings to rein in the conduct of Senators who, sitting in the “Upper House” with its more decorous, reflective and objective image, and not having any constituents to appease, should be less prone to indulge in the passions and aggression of the inter-party political battle.

In censuring unruly members, Dr Baboolal said: “I have seen members of this Honourable House shout across at each other, call each other names, ignore the rulings of the Chair, threaten the Chair, engage in loud cross-talk, waste the Parliament’s time by participating in irrelevancy and repetition and show disregard for the Standing Orders of the Senate.” The Senate President added: “I will he failing in my duty if I do not take the steps necessary to reverse this trend of behaviour in the House, which is slowly becoming unruly and disrespectful.” Her warning appears to be a timely one which, we expect, will serve its intended purpose and be digested by at least one particular Opposition Senator who may be the chief offender in this regard — at a recent session, he packed up and walked out in a huff, loudly declaiming her ruling as “an abomination”.

This clearly is unacceptable behaviour particularly since the Senator is experienced enough to know that the Standing Orders do not permit him to refer to matters transpiring in the other place and he should not be peeved when he is prevented from doing so. In our view, what the President of the Senate and the Speaker of the House should be most concerned about is the maintenance of proper procedure in the Parliament by the rigidly impartial application of the rules. Experience has shown that the even-handedness of the Chair will always be challenged but, in the final analysis, the obvious independence and fairness of the Speaker and President, their equitable approach to administering the rules, is the best and only way of dealing with unruly members and ensuring the decorum and effectiveness of the nation’s parliament.

The birth of a mini labasse


Do you, can you remember how neat and squeaky-clean were our roadsides in the week or three before we hosted the Miss Universe contest?

The gentleman who hailed me by name in the new, neat, squeaky-clean piazza of the National Library obviously had fond memories of those few weeks when he asked me to highlight the state of those roads today. Musing on his words I found the following piece among my yellowing press cuttings, which, I hope, may persuade a few more of us to think twice before dropping the least bit of litter anywhere in public — including the depths of the bush . . . “When Errol flung a chicken n’ chips box (bones and plastic fork included) out of a route taxi at 7 pm one Saturday night, he never thought it could inspire a feature in the Sunday Press. It wasn’t much of an eyesore. It was just one box.

The next stray dog to pass that way would eat the bones. The rain would soak the box to a soapy-grey pulp of cardboard, wax and roadside grit. Only the small plastic fork would remain there for the next six months — or however long it took the sun to destroy that piece of plastic. In the meantime, who would notice a small white plastic fork? Around 7.15 pm along came teenagers Clyde and Karl, driving Clyde’s father’s luxury car while draining the last drops of liquid from cartons of juice. Half a kilometre before they reached Errol’s abandoned chicken n’chips box, Clyde slowed the car, pressed a button and the electrically-operated window whined down. A blast of hot, humid air rushed into the air-conditioned car while Clyde tossed out the cartons, complete with plastic straws. He pressed the button again, the window slid up and Clyde drove on.

The juice cartons tumbled end over end to come to rest a metre or two away from Errol’s chicken n’chips box. There were now three pieces of garbage by the roadside — but it didn’t look too bad as yet, just untidy. It was around 7.30 pm when Basdeo and Anisa, Ibrahim and Jaitoon passed that spot in a small car. They all preferred the popular imported soft drinks in ring-topped cans to the locally manufactured juices in tetra packs. Rings and tins clattered as they hurled all four out of the car. They left behind what had now become a chequerboard of cans and rings, cartons and plastic straws — and the original chicken n’chips box and bones — nor should we forget the plastic fork. With seven pieces of garbage strewn along the roadside, it was beginning to look a mite untidy,

Meanwhile Ken and Iris and Winston and Joy, Avelina and Carmen and David and Frank were all in a chartered PTSC bus tucking into the pizzas they’d bought before they boarded the vehicle. At 7.45 pm, the boxes and napkins and bits of pizza they couldn’t finish sailed out of the windows of that PTSC bus to join the rings and cans and cartons and chicken n’ chips box — and that plastic fork. By this time the roadside was not a pretty sight. The night wore on. Careless of the returns on empty bottles, “Fingers” Tom, “Smartman” Dick, “Sneakers” Harry thought they might as well add not only crown corks, but their empty beer bottles to the roadside garbage collection. As the night wore on more crown corks and bottles, more cans and ring tops, more cartons and straws and chicken n’ chips boxes (and forks) were added to that growing garbage heap.

Daylight came. Seeing the heap, passers-by on foot added their quota of empty cigarette packs and cartons, plastic bags and whatever else they found far too heavy to carry to the nearest garbage bin — or to their own homes. As he drove along that road around midday, the new Labasse attracted the attention of the driver of an old American automobile. He slowed, then drove on. The following night he returned, stopped, got out of his ageing car, opened the trunk, dragged out an old mattress and heaved that on top of the heap, which, by now, was an established garbage dump.

Days went by. Each day more chicken n’chips boxes, ring-topped cans, tetra packs and straws, used tissues, cigarette packs and assorted small empty boxes were tossed on that dump. Each night cars came, stopped, the trunk opened, there were grunts and groans of something heavy being hauled out of the car and on to the dump. Dawn revealed a rusting gas stove or washing machine or set of wrecked Samsonite dinette chairs and a table missing one leg on top of, or spreading outwards from the heap. Another dawn might see eight sheets of rusting galvanise, a cardboard box of builder’s rubble, a bag of household garbage.

As the weeks wore on, coconut branches, tree trimmings and garden rubbish of every shape and size were dumped on that heap together with rusting iron bedsteads, half a bicycle, an overstuffed armchair leaking stuffing and termite dust. And more and more boxes and bottles, cans and cartons. Eventually along came Press photographer C D Liter who, seeing what looked like a good shot for a feature in the Sunday paper that was in the throes of an anti-litter, clean scene campaign, asked the taxi driver to stop. He heaved his heavy camera bag out of the taxi. Checked that he had film in the camera — noting a box that had once held film on the heap. He took several shots to make sure he had the most dramatic photo. And that was how Errol’s chicken n’chips box laid the foundation for a big feature photo in the Sunday Press. But, as Errol knew quite well, not a single reader could see his chicken n’ chips box — or the small plastic fork . . .”

Problems mount for Windies

GEORGETOWN: The West Indies new-look cricket team will have only one training session together before the First Test against Australia after an apparent mix-up over travel arrangements sent a group of players flying around the Caribbean on a detour.

West Indian officials were at a loss yesterday to explain why four players were sent backtracking to Jamaica after playing the final of the Carib Beer International Challenge final in Barbados on Sunday instead of making the short hop direct to Guyana. Jamaica is roughly three hours’ flying time west of Barbados while Guyana is just over one hour directly to the south. The result was that late on Tuesday night only seven of the players arrived in Georgetown where the First Test gets under way at Bourda today.

The incident was the latest blow to the West Indies’ preparations following the decision of former captain Carl Hooper to pull out of the team and the confusion over whether Jamaican opener Chris Gayle was eligible to play. “Seven players arrived last night, four Jamaicans, two Barbadians and one Antiguan,” said team manager Ricky Skerritt, adding that travel arrangments had been made in conjunction with the Jamaica and Barbados cricket boards. But he added: “We are happy to have the squad here today and they are out there now working very hard and getting ready for the match.” West Indies Cricket Board (WICB) chief executive Roger Brathwaite said he would look into the incident.

The problem came a day after Hooper, who was sacked as captain following first round elimination at the World Cup in South Africa, pulled out of the squad, saying he did not want to stand in the way of younger talent. Jamaica’s Gayle was overlooked after not making himself available for the domestic final against Barbados, but the rules have been questioned with some commentators claiming that Gayle could have played and he may be back for the Second Test. Captain Brian Lara admitted that the Hooper pull-out was a blow on both the batting and bowling fronts. “We were depending on Carl Hooper to do a lot of bowling (as well), he’s always been a good off-spinner,” Lara said. Referring to Gayle, he said: “We have got our best 14 players here for the Test match. I don’t think it was a premature decision by the selectors. “Hopefully, Chris will be in the team for the Second Test.” 

Test debut for Grenada’s Smith

GEORGETOWN: Devon Smith was named yesterday — for his Test debut — in the West Indies’ final 11 for the first Cable and Wireless Test Match against Australia, starting at Bourda Oval today.

The 21-year-old left-handed opening batsman blessed with an array of strokes, has gained his place following two seasons of heavy scoring in the West Indies first class domestic competition. He will become the third player from Grenada — after Junior Murray and Rawl Lewis — to play Test cricket for the West Indies. The West Indies embark today on their daunting task of regaining the Sir Frank Worrell Trophy they lost to the Australians in 1995, and team captain Brian Lara believes his squad is ready. West Indies cricket has been lashed by potentially unsettling issues in the past week, but Lara is brushing the off-the-field issues aside.

Carl Hooper’s withdrawal from the team, the surprising omission of opening batsman Chris Gayle, and Australian Bennett King turning down the West Indies coaching job after being named by the West Indies Cricket Board (WICB) as their pick to take over soon, Lara suggests, are not psychologically adverse issues with the players. “The team is a very young team and seem to be unperturbed by what’s happening,” Lara said at a pre-series press conference at the Pegasus Hotel yesterday morning. “I’ve got a job to do, I’ve got to go out there and lead the West Indies team. Presently I am in the best frame of mind possible to do so, the guys are very happy to be here, mentally I think we’ve got to deal with the Australian cricket team. “There is no psychological advantage to the Australians because of what’s happening,” Lara said.

Four years ago when the teams met the last time here in the Caribbean, the series ended 2-2, and Lara, who had a magnificent series then, thinks the current squad is improved and equipped to be competitive again. “I think the team (recently) has been moving forward, just a different leader, at present considering four years ago I think we have a better team, batting-wise at least.  “This team is a more mature team, a team that we can depend a lot more on. I’ll back the West Indian players to come out and give a good account of themselves,” he said. Australia’s captain Steve Waugh will become Test cricket’s most-capped player when he takes the field today for his 157th match, eclipsing Allan Border’s old record.


West Indies team — Brian Lara (captain), Wavell Hinds, Daren Ganga, Devon Smith, Shivnarine Chanderpaul, Marlon Samuels, Ridley Jacobs, Vasbert Drakes, Pedro Collins, Mervyn Dillon, Jermaine Lawson. Australian Squad — Steve Waugh (captain), Matthew Hayden, Justin Langer, Ricky Ponting, Martin Love, Darren Lehmann, Adam Gilchrist, Brad Hogg, Brett Lee, Jason Gillespie, Stuart MacGill, Andy Bichel. Umpires — Asoka de Silva (Sri Lanka) and Rudi Koertzen (South Africa). Match Referee — Mike Procter (South Africa).

‘Misguided’ Chris Gayle begs for forgiveness

KINGSTON: Chris Gayle of Jamaica acknowledged making a “misguided” decision to compete in the recent Double Wicket tournament, which he believes cost him a spot on the West Indies cricket team in their First Test match against Australia today. But the batsman defended his actions in a statement on Tuesday, saying he believes the West Indies Cricket Board had sanctioned the decision for him to participate in the tournament in St Lucia rather than play for Jamaica in the Carib Beer final against Barbados.

The Antigua-based West Indies Cricket Board was not immediately available for comment yesterday. “While I may have made a misguided decision, I do not believe I have done anything wrong,” the 23-year-old left-handed opener said. “I wish to assure everyone that I did not intend to do wrong and humbly seek your forgiveness and understanding.” “On the other hand, if as I suspect my non-selection stemmed from a clear and demonstrable misunderstanding of the rules relative to the eligibility for selection and my part in the Double Wicket competition, then I believe injustice has been done to me,” he said.

Gayle, a member of the West Indies squad to the recent World Cup in South Africa, withdrew from Jamaica’s team to the Carib Beer final to play alongside former West Indies captain Carl Hooper in the double wicket series. Jamaica’s national cricket team manager Lyndel Wright and captain Robert Samuels say they gave Gayle the green light to play in the tournament because they also felt that West Indies officials had approved his participation. Gayle has played 28 Tests for the West Indies since making his debut in 1999 against Zimbabwe in Trinidad and Tobago. He has scored two centuries, including a best score of 204 against New Zealand.