Pigeon Point issue to be heard Friday

HIGH COURT Judge Joseph Tam yesterday informed the attorneys representing Robinson Crusoe Ltd and the State that he was unable to proceed with the constitutional motion before the court due to other part-heard matters that were before him. However, he informed them that the matter would be given priority on Friday.

Attorneys appearing for Robinson Crusoe Ltd yesterday were due to begin presenting their legal arguments before the court to seek an injunction to block the State from compulsorily acquiring the beach resort. When the matter was called, the judge asked Robinson Crusoe Ltd’s attorney Dr Fenton Ramsahoye QC how far they intended to proceed for the day. Dr Ramsahoye explained that they were prepared to have arguments for two days if the matter was heard for three hours on each occasion. The judge then informed Dr Ramsahoye that due to an incomplete matter before him, he would adjourn the matter to Friday. Dr Ramsahoye then enquired if the matter could be concluded on Friday, and Justice Tam informed him that it would be completed since both parties gave their assurance that their arguments would only last about two hours each. Attorney for the State Dr Lloyd Barnett informed the judge that the attorneys had their skeleton arguments in writing and advised that they be presented for the court’s assistance. Robinson Crusoe Ltd, a subsidiary of ANSA McAL and operators of Club Pigeon Point, filed the motion on July 4, claiming that the proposed acquisition of its property by the State was unconstitutional. Dr Barnett is assisted in the matter by Karen Fournillier, Terrance Thorne and John Jeremie instructed by Rohana Hosein, while Dr Ramsahoye and Rikki Harnanan instructed by Adrian Byrne appeared for Robinson Crusoe Ltd.

FFOS challenges EMA over Atlantic LNG

ENVIRONMENTAL group Fisherman and Friends of the Sea (FFOS) yesterday applied for judicial review of a decision taken by the Environmental Management Authority (EMA) on June 6, to grant a Certificate of Environmental Clearance (CEC) to Atlantic LNG.

The CEC was granted for the construction and operation of Train IV for the liquification of natural gas for the purpose of increasing LNG production at the LNG facility at Point Fortin.  The application, which was filed by attorney Darrell P Allahar on behalf of the FFOS stated that the decision taken on June 6, was unlawful. The application was filed on the grounds of  illegality, procedural impropriety, unreasonableness and irrationality by the EMA. In addition FFOS is claiming that the decision and/ or action of the EMA amount to an abuse or misuse of public power. Another ground was that the action and discretion of the EMA in succumbing to pressures political and/ or otherwise, amounted to an improper delegation of the exercise of its powers. Attorneys Ramesh Lawrence Maharaj and Rajendra Ramlogan are expected to represent FFOS in the matter.

RHA’s have doctors’ money

The Regional Health Authorities (RHAs) have received lump sum cheques to pay the arrears owed to doctors, Health Minister Colm Imbert said yesterday.

He said the loan for the back pay “took a little while” but payment should not take long. On Tuesday, the Medical Profes-sionals Association contradicted a statement made by Planning and Development Minister Dr Keith Rowely that doctors had received their outstanding arrears. At a media briefing over a week ago, Rowley said the PNM government had to get a $40.8 million loan for the arrears owed from the December 6, 2001 Memorandum of Agreement signed between the RHAs and the PSA.

Speaking to the media, Imbert confirmed that only doctors in the Public Service have received arrears. “Their salaries are a direct charge on the Ministry of Health whereas the RHA salaries are from an allocation from the RHAs.” A loan was needed since the RHAs did not have the money to cover the back pay. Imbert  has asked the RHAs to supply him with the name of every doctor who has been paid.

Police keep close watch over Gordon

THE TRINIDAD and Tobago Police Service (TTPS) has “intelligence information” relative to the alleged plot to kidnap and kill First Citizens Bank (FCB) chairman, Ken Gordon, acting Commission-er of Police Everald Snaggs told reporters yesterday on the VMCOTT compound.

“I have not spoken to Mr Gordon myself, but I have read reports in the papers.  I know that we have some intelligence information and we are working on it,” Snaggs told the media. The top cop did not want to elaborate on what the intelligence information is, saying: “As you would realise it’s not appropriate, but it’s sensitive and we are working on that information.” Newsday reported yesterday that there was an alleged plot to kidnap and kill Gordon, who in a telephone interview said that “official security people” has told him to be careful and that he is doing just that. A senior police official said police are paying attention to Gordon and that the intelligence information received was not from the Special Branch.

They referred Newsday to FCB.  However, the bank’s communication manager Dara Healy said yesterday her department has not been given any word or directive on it. Snaggs also commented on the disabled people who have been occupying space outside the National Flour Mills (NFM) compound, Wright-son Road, for about 93 days now. He said files on alleged abuse on the workers have been sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Geoffrey Henderson for advice.

ADB/UTC get record deposits

Caroni workers who recently received their VSEP payments made history this week collectively depositing more than $40 million to the Agricultural Development Bank (ADB) and the Unit Trust Corporation (UTC) in exchange for the offer of no-payback loans plus capital gains.

On Monday alone, the ADB recorded more than $12 million in deposits, which according to bank representatives, is the largest single volume of deposits for any one day in the history of the financial institution. The UTC itself took in $8 million in VSEP cheques from Caroni workers on Monday, also a record for the Corporation. More than one billion dollars is being paid out by Government to Caroni workers as it attempts to rationalise the operations of Caroni and relieve the debt facing the company. Tuesday saw a repeat of the previous day with ADB and UTC offices throughout the country being overrun with large crowds packing the halls and depositing another $20 million. The demand has been so great that both the ADB and the UTC have proposed to open their offices from 8 am to noon on Saturday. This will also be a first for both institutions.

Chairman of the ADB as well as the UTC, Hubert Alleyne, noted that this unique programme of no-payback loans, as well as capital gains of VSEP earnings deposited with either institution, was devised to help the workers make the most productive use of their VSEP. He explained that the $1 billion payout by the State was the largest ever severance payment in the history of the country. Alleyne noted further that as loans will be repaid in approximately six years on an interest rate of eight percent per annum, net gains are projected for transactions.

Men threaten staff

The Sangre Grande Health Centre (SGHC) at Henderson Street was yesterday forced to shut its doors after two men threatened to “shoot up the place and kill people.”

Workers are traumatised by the episode and the facility will reopen on Monday with an additional security guard on duty. Reports indicate that at 7am yesterday the lone Maintenance Training and Security (MTS) guard on duty was distributing numbers to people waiting to see the dentist. Fewer numbers were handed out because the dentists had a meeting to attend. Two men who were unable to get numbers became irate despite being given an explanation. They demanded immediate treatment. The guard asked them to leave and from outside the Centre they shouted threats. One of the men said when he saw them on the street they would get “a few slugs.” A gun was reportedly seen. The episode caused the closure of the Health Centre and workers refused to work until more security guards are hired.

A worker said the incident is the “climax” of the problems experienced at the facility. She said there are frequent break-ins and verbal abuse disgruntled persons “nearly every Monday.” The facility is often crowded because insufficient seats are available. She said a new building is needed. A report has been made with the Sangre Grande police and investigations are being conducted by Cpl Deosaran and PC Khan. However, yesterday Essau Mohammed, Chief Executive Officer for the Eastern Regional Health Authority (which manages the SGHC) who  met with staff about the incident, told Newsday that only one man had threatened staff. He said an additional guard has been requested from MTS, in addition to them having “some level of defence.”

Mark blanks Yetming on CCJ

UNITED National Congress chairman Wade Mark yesterday said he was not interested in the position St Joseph MP Gerald Yetming takes when legislation to establish the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) comes before Parliament in September.

That legislation requires a special majority for passage and Government would have to gain the support of at least four Opposition MPs. Prime Minister Patrick Manning indicated last Thurs-day that he planned to canvass UNC MPs individually to get support for the legislation. Yetming told Newsday on Monday that he believes that the UNC’s strategy of refusing to support the court needs to be revisited by the party’s parliamentary caucus. However Mark said he was uninterested in whatever decision Yetming takes on the CCJ. The UNC chairman stated that the party’s main priority was rebuilding itself following last month’s Local Government Elections, which it lost to the ruling People’s National Movement (PNM). He disclosed that UNC Elections Officer Dr Tim Gopeesingh is now heading a revamped constitution commission and will begin a series of meetings next week with the party’s regional groups as to how the UNC’s constitution should be reformed.

The UNC chairman was optimistic that this process will be completed by De-cember. The party’s internal elections are scheduled to be held either in December or early 2004. On Monday, UNC Political Leader Basdeo Panday was uncertain whether he would stand for re-election and declined to say who among the UNC’s current cadre of parliamentarians could be a likely successor to him. Since October 2002, Panday has expressed his desire to retire from active politics at age 70 but has stressed that he would not abandon the UNC in mid-stream because the party would be vulnerable to political “predators”. Panday identified former UNC deputy leader Ramesh Lawrence Maharaj as one such predator.

Kobe back in court October 9

EAGLE: Kobe Bryant, the NBA superstar accused of sexually assaulting a 19-year-old hotel worker, made his first appearance in a Colorado court yesterday amid a media frenzy.

Flanked by his attorneys, the 24-year-old Bryant stood quietly as his attorneys waived his right to be formally advised of the felony assault charge. Eagle County Judge Frederick Gannett set a preliminary hearing for October 9. Bryant has said he had consensual sex with the woman but is innocent of assault. Bryant, who is free on $25,000 bond, said virtually nothing during the seven-minute hearing. He left the courthouse immediately and was expected to leave Colorado soon after the court appearance.

The hearing was held amid a media frenzy akin to the NBA finals. Hundreds of reporters and photographers swamped this quiet mountain town and the brief hearing involving the five-time All Star was broadcast live on national cable networks. Bryant took a private jet to a nearby airport and was driven to the Eagle County courthouse in a sport-utility vehicle. There were scattered cheers and a shout of “Kobe is innocent!” from the crowd after he arrived. Outside the courthouse, a small city of television satellite trucks was set up next to a dozen or so platforms for live television shots —  precisely the type of coverage Bryant was hoping to avoid when his attorneys asked Gannett to allow the Lakers star to skip the procedural hearing.  The judge denied the request, setting the stage for the circus-like event.

At times, preparation for Bryant’s arrival looked more like something for a head of state. A media tent was erected outside the courthouse, authorities brought out the county’s only metal detector, and sheriff’s deputies were called in on overtime to keep order. Along with the journalists came Bryant’s fans — people like Eric Tison, 30, who drove three hours. “I hope he’s innocent. I’m here to support him as a basketball player,” said Tison, wearing a Los Angeles Lakers No 8 jersey and hoping for an autograph. “What goes on in his personal life now is taking away from the game.” 

Cruisers sing the blues


Trinidad was once hailed by yachtsmen as the ultimate destination for repairs and supplies. But over the last three years this view has changed. No longer is Trinidad the place to go, some cruisers (yachties) say.

Yachties have been complaining about higher prices for goods and services, the “quality” of the anchorages and the “ugly” waters (See Letter)  Those who have experienced the Chaguaramas’ dark side have been spreading the word across the yachting community, and as a result, the numbers of boats coming in have decreased since 2000. Yachties claim they can get better service at cheaper rates from the other islands like Martinique, Venezuela, St Martin, Grenada and Antigua. And now, a once flourishing industry is battling to regain its image as a boating destination. “Chaguaramas looks good on paper,” one cruiser said, who spoke on condition of anonymity. “But when you get here it’s something different.” Another said with prices going up, she may look to go up the islands. In addition, the spiralling crime rate and rise in the cost of services have done nothing to improve the yachties’ view of Trinidad. The Yacht Services Association (YSATT) though has been putting measures in place to deal with the concerns of the yachting community.

According to YSATT’s Vice President, Christopher Marshall, people are only seeing the cruisers’ perspective.  He said because a few yachties have spoken out against Trinidad, the association and the contractors have been feeling the negative backlash. “We get the feeling that because of the voices of a few, the situation has been blown out of proportion,” said Marshall. Cruisers dismissed this view, saying that they are just telling it like it is. “Is Chaguaramas losing its appeal ? asked one cruiser, who had been coming for about five years. “I would say that it is.” One cruiser noted though that the area still has a lot to offer, but that perhaps the YSATT had become complacent. Marshall said YSATT recently conducted a survey and over 80 percent of the boating population visiting Trinidad said they loved it and would come again. He added that like with any other industry, there will be some who have bad experiences, but since the yachtsmen are a travelling community, the words of a few can spread like a brushfire.

According to Marshall, YSATT has been working diligently to calm their fears and trying to increase the number of active boats on the dock. Active boats are those with repairs being done to them while docked. He said YSATT is also aware of the yachties’ concern about crime in the area. One or two have been directly affected with their dinghies being stolen of their boats and a few were mugged while traveling into Port-of-Spain. This has left others feeling unsafe. To quell the fears of the cruisers in this regard, YSATT is organising a water taxi service for them. “The water taxi will be commissioned in the next few months. It will go from yard to yard via the water so that at night the yacht men can move around without having to use the main roads where they feel unsafe,” said Marshall. The water taxi will also have a communication system on board in case of emergencies. Also, YSATT has approached the Coast Guard and the police to help secure the area with patrols at night. But this may be a bigger task than the association can accomplish in the near future.

Marshall said the Carenage police station has only one police car and the facilities are deplorable. “The toilets are horrible and there are fowls and rats running about. And the building is up a side street and not in the public view,” said Marshall. So concerned is YSATT that the organisation recently met with Prime Minister Patrick Manning.  Marshall said YSATT has been in talks with the PM for the last few months trying to arrange better facilities for the police station, but so far they have had no real progress. The yachties also claim that contractors’ prices have sky-rocketed over the past few years. According to Marshall, prices have gone up but with good reason. “When we entered the market ten years ago to develop the local yachting industry, we tried to get market share with competitive pricing,” said Marshall. He said the industry was made of up a lot of inexperienced contractors trying to gain a foothold and compete with more developed yachting industries throughout the Caribbean. The word spread through the yachting community that Trinidad offered cheap rates for good work, “and they came to expect this over the years,” he said. “This has had a negative impact on us,” Marshall said, noting that the larger contractors are now in a position to increase the cost of their services.  “Ten years later, yachties feel it is unfair. They come expecting to get something for nothing,” said Marshall.

The cruisers have grown accustomed to being spoiled in Trinidad and now that things have changed, they feel they have been cheated. But that is not the case, said Marshall. “If you do a survey of pricing throughout the Caribbean and the rest of the world, you will realize that our pricing is still very competitive as far as labor rates go,” he said. But some of the concerns of the cruisers may be justified since pricing on some of the land facilities are high. By law yachties are allowed to bring goods into Trinidad duty free, as long as they are consigned to their boats. But when they need to purchase supplies, cruisers have to incur duty and Vat on all items, and as a result they pay higher for goods here than in other islands. This, said Marshall will encourage them bringing in their own goods and not patronize the local stores. Marshall said Trinidad’s major competitors, St Martin, Antigua and Grenada all have duty free and tax free status for goods sold within the industry and competing against this is turning out to be a hard task for the local yachting businesses. “We have recognized this as a valid complaint and are currently working on gaining the support of the Government to enforce a duty free status for us,” said Marshall. YSATT has been trying to change the image of Trinidad from the land of cheap labor.  Marshall said their main goal right now, apart from ensuring those docking in Trinidad feel safe, is to create an image of quality work at reasonable prices. He said in order to build a viable, dependable industry this perception of “something for nothing” has to be eliminated even if it means facing negative repercussions from a small percent of the market. The task for YSATT is not to increase the number of boats that visit our docks, but to increase the amount of money the boats that do come, spend here, he added.

What has happened?

‘First, we want to tell everyone that we love Trinidad! We could write many pages of the wonderful aspects of Trinidad. Since 2000, we visited twice a year and always anchor at TTSA in Chaguaramas and had great times.

But today, we notice that Trinidad is losing its appeal among the boating community. Everywhere in the Caribbean, we have met complaining cruisers who are now skipping Trinidad as a destination. Our friends look astonished when we say nice words about Trinidad. WHAT HAS HAPPENED? Back in 2000, we were going south along the chain of islands and from cockpit to cockpit, the comments were suggesting for us to wait until Trinidad; a great place on the move. A great place for repairs, affordable prices, and businesses devoted to boaters, even if the workers were not yet fully experienced. In the winter of 2002, we sailed again along the chain of islands. What a contrast! A new song was being played. From cockpit to cockpit, the comments were suggesting that there is no advantage to go to Trinidad for repairs: Prices are higher. Better workshops at affordable prices could be found in other countries. The industry seemed less devoted to the cruisers in their attitude. The climate is too humid. Anchorages are not adequate and the water is ugly. What a radical change in perception and only two years later! We agree that there are fewer boats in the Caribbean, but it seems to us that Trinidad is losing an important share of the available market. We are astonished. Even the well renowned TTSA for its hospitality, is losing its reputation with cruisers feeling less welcome.

WHAT HAS HAPPENED to this fast growing Chaguaramas that now looks like a declining star? Trinidad has so much to offer in people, atmosphere, tours, events and choices of stores. Last fall, a general tendency among the boaters’ community was to be in Martinique for Christmas. Martinique is nice but there is nothing in that country related to the Christmas period. The only place in the whole Caribbean for a real ambience of Christmas is Trinidad. How come Trinidad does not promote a Christmas rendezvous? As an example, the free shuttle, organised last year by YSATT, was one of the best initiatives to protect the cruisers from harm. Cruisers are sensitive to the growing phenomenon of crime. No other country seemed even to care, yet how come so few acknowledged this positive action to protect the security of the cruisers? Moreover, Venezuela is unsafe in many locations, yet this year the marinas in Puerto La Cruz were full. By our count, over one hundred boats were anchored in Porlamar, Margarita. Yes, the prices are attractive and many boaters we talked to were absolutely not interested in Trinidad. We were deeply saddened! We observe this lack of appeal! In writing these observations, we do not want to blame or judge anybody. We only hope that Trinidad will wake up and do something to regain its appeal. We are only foreign boaters and visitors. We only wish to meet our returning friends here again, with pleasure, on their boats in this beautiful and active country.’ (This letter appeared in the July issue of Boca, a ysatt publication)