Hospital workers jobless

Wards’ maids, hospital and mortuary attendants who have been getting employment through the Public Service Commission (PSC) for the past year should have been working with the Regional Health Authorities since their positions became redundant with the Public Service since December 31, 1996. A slip up at the hospital or Ministry level has resulted in these workers continuing to receive employment in the Public Service. Classified as temporary Public Servants, the wards’ maids and attendants provide “leave relief” at hospitals. Last week, a group of them complained about job losses after finding out they can no longer get letters of continuation of service from the Public Service Commission. They were advised that the RHAs were responsible for hiring them.

The move caught many by surprise because they have been working regularly for the past three or more years. However, an official of the Health Ministry said the workers should not have been receiving letters of continuation. The Ministry and Public Services Association (the union representing PS health workers) reached an agreement in 1996 that all temporary (health specific) posts will not go to the PSC for the period of their employment to be extended. Employment was guaranteed with the RHAs. He said persons may have “slipped” through because hospital or Ministry officials did not stick to the agreement. However, this month, the Ministry wrote to the PSC stating that it will no longer request temporary positions. The RHAs are responsible for filling all vacancies. The Health Ministry has directed the RHAs to give “first preference” for any employment opportunity to the workers previously employed through the PSC.

THA: ATLA must approve ‘cancellation fee’

BWIA and Tobago Express must get the approval of the Air Transport Licensing Authority (ATLA) before they institute any fee to penalise persons who book flights to travel on the domestic airbridge but do not show up. That was the word yesterday from Secretary of Tourism/Transportation/Enterprise Development/Settlements at the Tobago House of Assembly (THA), Neil Wilson. The question of the implementation of what is being widely referred to as a “cancellation fee” has become the subject of much public debate in Tobago since the proposal was put forward by the affected airlines who claim that the no-show among booked passengers had now escalated into a serious problem. In fact, Tobago Express has reported that some 25 percent of booked passengers regularly do not travel nor call to cancel their flights.

This, the airline claims, results in persons wishing to commute on the airbridge having to do so on standby tickets. It is against this background that the airlines proposed the implementation of a penalty/fee — $100 was suggested — for these no-show passengers. However, responding to a Newsday query at yesterday’s post-Executive Council meeting press briefing, Wilson explained: “The airlines who intend to use the ‘‘cancellation fee”, and most likely it will be BWIA and Tobago Express, would have to make an application to the ATLA who has the jurisdiction over fares: over passenger fares, over cargo fares, mail charges and so on. So they need to get permission from ATLA in order to do this; it isn’t automatic, it doesn’t operate that way!” he told Newsday. Wilson acknowledged that as things stand at present, it is “only a proposal.”

TT needs to close the gap between GDP and GNP

Trinidad and Tobago needs to close the gap between its Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and its Gross National Product (GNP) if we hope to gain a developed nation status, according to Eric Williams, Minister of Energy and Energy Industries. Williams was speaking at the Emancipation Support Committee, Trans-Atlantic International Trade and Investment Symposium at the Hilton Trinidad yesterday. The week-long symposium centred on the energy sector, particularly in terms of trading with Africa. It dealt also in part with finding economic freedom through energy ties between Caricom and Africa. Williams based his declaration on the World Bank listing of the most developed nations. He listed three success factors that will assist us in becoming a developed nation. “We must increase the level of economic diversification, increase the level of value added trade and investment and encourage small and medium businesses along with the private sector to develop in quantum leaps,” said Williams. He added that small and private businesses have the potential to contribute 40 percent of the GDP to TT and this potential needs to be encouraged.

TT currently falls into the upper middle income bracket and while we strive to reach higher income or US$9266 per capita or more, the standards to obtain this keep rising. Our GDP is currently US$7,200 per capita. Williams also said that TT’s key advantage for sustaining and growing markets for energy is transportation. It takes about 5 days to ship LNG to the US from Trinidad, which is faster than transporting within the US. The Government intends to intensify the links between the energy and the non-energy sector, he added.

Reforms for Local Govt coming

LOCAL GOVERNMENT will be experiencing challenging times in the years ahead, according to Jarette Narine, Minister of Local Government. Speaking at the swearing-in ceremony at the Couva/ Tabaquite/Talparo Regional Corporation on Tuesday, the Minister said that the Government would be reviewing the Local Government Act and as such “we would be expecting the full co-operation of all Corp-orations in this exercise before the final Bill is laid in Parliament. “We are not there as yet but we are getting there,” he added. Speaking to the newly elected members of the Corporation, the Minister said that he was “ready and committed” to work alongside them and give every assistance to make the Corporation and their tenure of office a very successful one.

He admitted that “considering the landmark and size of your Corpora-tion, you have done very well, and for the future, I also wish you very well.” The Minister said that he himself was a County Councillor for eight years and from his experience, he was pleased to state publicly that “our system is unique.” He told the gathering that there woud be reforms in the Local Government framework of the country and the final Bill would be laid in Parliament shortly. Narine said that there were many “perceptions of Local Government and we are attempting to arrive at proposals that would be most acceptable to the population.” The Minister said that Government would continue to give allocations to Corporations who must continue their programme of work on a priority basis. He stressed that allocation of funds was done equitably across the board in the country and even though expressing much confidence in the new  CEO, he advised Councils to “manage funds and money properly as it was not an easy thing to do.” Narine congratulated the last Chairman, Councillor Ranjit Ramnarine, for managing the affairs of the Corporation from July last year to July this year without a Council.

Tobago game wardens ‘appointed’ after 50 years

Game Wardens in Tobago, who have all been working in “temporary” positions in some cases as far back as the 1950s, have now been regularised. The longstanding vexing issue, over which the disgruntled wardens have been agitated for years, was recently resolved via a Cabinet Note, according to Chief Secretary of the Tobago House of Assembly, Orville London. 

According to the Cabinet Note, dated July 17, six Game Wardens I and one Game Warden II have now been “appointed” in Tobago. “These ‘temporary’ game wardens, some of them, who had been temporary from as far back as the 1950s, their positions have now been regularised,” he disclosed. “That has now been settled and the game wardens, who were extremely frustrated, and justifiably so, can now have their appointments,” London told Newsday during an interview last Friday following discussions between the Public Service Commission and a THA delegation at the THA Administrative Complex at Calder Hall.

IT for vision 2020

TRINIDAD and Tobago, with the rest of the world, has entered the Age of Information and there is no need to emphasise the fact that our progress as a nation will depend on how comprehensively we grasp and utilise this amazing technology. The business of government, every profession, every productive enterprise, indeed almost every aspect of our personal life and development proceed, to a determining and decisive extent, on our command and use of Information and Communication Technology. So crucial and pervasive has this technology become, in fact, that Hollywood could produce a hit movie fantasizing about these high-tech machines being used to take over the world and launch doomsday, the stuff of Terminator III. It goes without saying, then, that small developing countries must, at the very least, become fully functional in ICT if they are not to be left behind. For Trinidad and Tobago, aspiring to achieve developed nation status by 2020, the need to master the use of computers and modern communication systems is imperative. In this regard, we think it is necessary for students at secondary and tertiary level to have access to computers and training in the use of the technology. Becoming literate in this area, in our view, is now just as important as learning to read and write and calculate effectively. The large foreign corporations and multi-nationals who have extensive investments in our country’s energy sector will be doing themselves a favour if they assist the country in this objective.

In any case, the basic responsibility for TT acquiring this technological facility lies with the Government which, it is assuring to see, recognises the need and is devising strategies to achieve it. According to Minister in the Ministry of Finance, Senator Christine Sahadeo, the Government intends to provide education and training at all levels in the areas of computer literacy, Internet usage, e-commerce and associated technologies. The Senator was delivering her first public address at the inaugural session of the Workshop for e-commerce Competitiveness for Small Business Development in the Caribbean Region, held at the Hilton on Monday. She disclosed that the workshop was part of Government’s national plan for the Development of the Information and Communication Technology Sector, which it regarded as critical to the modernisation of TT. The emphasis, she added, would be placed on the development of world class communication and computer infrastructure, as well as the further liberalisation of trade, telecommunications and information technology. The plan also makes it clear that we cannot develop e-commerce to the fullest if large sections of the population remain uninvolved and untouched by the development of the information, communications and technology sectors. The intention is to make it easier, as well as more affordable for the public to gain access to the Internet and associated technologies “so that citizens can benefit from the numerous opportunities provided by an electronically driven environment.” The Senator’s articulation of the country’s need and Government’s response to it is commendable but she was short on details for the practical implementation of the plan. The training in and use of technology is a hands-on exercise, requiring a connection between user and machine. What method, what organisation, what system the Government plans to use to get the population involved is still to be seen. 

THE LONG JOURNEY FROM EMANCIPATION

 



The British planter class, aided and abetted by the British Government, viewed African slaves as their personal property, without legal rights, and viewed the formal abolition of slavery as a needless imposition. And the slaves were ‘freed’, not for any humanitarian reason, but because slavery had become uneconomic and would have been increasingly so in the long term. Indeed, almost as if to dispose of the ‘humanitarian theory’, the United Kingdom Government in its Abolition of Slavery Act of 1833, would state that “a reasonable Compensation should be made to the Persons hitherto entitled to the services of such Slaves for the Loss which they will incur by being deprived of their Right to such Services”. It was a dismissal of any thought that they could and should be considered as human beings. While the slaves were not given any payment, either by way of gratuity or pension for their years of forced labour, the slave ‘owners’ however, received 20 million pounds sterling as compensation. To this day, the descendants of those who were forcibly removed from Africa, brutalised and exploited, have never received reparations or even considered for such.

The non-compensating of slaves was designed to force them to remain in the employ of the estates, and when this was resisted, both because work on the estates reminded them of their earlier forced labour, and the wage offered was small the plantation owners adopted tactics that, by any standards, were wicked and cruel. The planter class charged exorbitant rents for accommodation and for the lands which the former slaves tilled on their own. They destroyed their crops. The former slave masters determined that the abolition of slavery should profit them three ways. The compensation given them by an accommodating British Government; the fact that they no longer had to house, clothe, feed and even provide limited medical care to the slaves, and the offering of wages that were clearly less than what it would have cost them to maintain slaves. The Governor of Trinidad and the law enforcement agencies, including Special Magistrates, co-ordinated efforts in an attempt to frustrate the former African slaves from leaving the land and moving to the towns. A law was introduced requiring former slaves, who relocated to the towns to either obtain employment within 24 hours, and provide the authorities with proof of this, or risk being taken before a Magistrate where he/she could be deemed idle and disorderly and sent to prison. In 1842, eight years after the abolition of slavery and some four years after the end of the Apprenticeship system, first class field workers in Trinidad were paid a daily wage of 50 cents; in St. Vincent, this would range from 16 to 24 cents a day; in St. Lucia, from 16 to 48 cents a day; in Barbados,  29 cents; 40 to 48 cents in British Guiana [now Guyana], and in Grenada  21 cents a day.
 
Because of the relatively wide differences in wages between those obtaining in the islands of the English speaking Eastern Caribbean and Trinidad and Tobago and Guiana, scores of people migrated to BG and Trinidad to seek employment. They would soon abandon jobs on the estates. Plantation owners in Trinidad and Guiana pressured the UK Government to introduce indentured immigrants from India to work on estates, and meet their estates’ needs so that sugar cane could be planted, reaped and sent to the factories. Guiana was the first to introduce indentureship in a short lived and later reintroduced scheme, with the first two batches of just under 400 indentured Indians arriving there in May of 1838 on the Hesperus and Whitby. The importing of indentured labour from India was meant to crush the reluctance of former slaves to work on estates. The choice of Indian labour made for ‘good’ economics, particularly when you examine the brutally cynical arguments put forward by the then Governor of Guiana, Sir Henry Light, in a despatch to Lord Russell, the Secretary of State for the Colonies seeking to justify Indian indentureship. Russell in his reply to Light, dated February 15, 1840, would refer to Light’s arguments. One of them, quoted by Russell, was that “the wages of a day labourer are, in Guiana, 1s. 6d. [36 cents] per day, and in Hindostan not more than 2d. [four cents].” Indian indentureds, although subjected initially to harsh and oppressive treatment, had the advantage of being able to retain their religion, their customs, their languages, work under “contract of service” for five years with the option of either returning home, renewing their contracts or, receiving a parcel of land in lieu of repatriation.

Although, slaves had no such “contracts of service”, yet many, following on abolition, were able to rise above the many injustices meted out to them. According to a Resolution moved on July 25, 1842, in the British House of Commons, the fruits of a Committee headed by J. S. Parkington, [later to become Secretary of State] “many of the former slaves have been enabled to purchase land….and….the land they thus hold as owners or occupiers not only yields them an ample supply of food, but in many cases a considerable overplus in money…” But the determination of the plantation owners to have the former slaves back on the land, despite the importation of indentured labour, had assumed even greater emphasis, with the realisation that African slaves had daily production levels 33 1/3 per cent higher than that of the Indian indentureds!  Educational opportunities for the children of former slaves was, initially, severely limited, and the “Negro Education Grant” was effected by the UK Government in 1835. It represented the lordly sum of 25,000 pounds sterling a year, and was not for Trinidad alone,  This was solely for primary or elementary education, and it was not until 1859 that the Government of Trinidad would establish the Queen’s Collegiate School, later to be renamed The Queen’s Royal College. For the record, the Queen’s Collegiate School was built mainly for the children of the white planter class and white officials, and only a handful of blacks were actually admitted.

Defeat for our political system

THE EDITOR: A great deal has been revealed by the results of the 2003 Local Government Elections. Those revelations can easily be seen as the final, much needed indictment on our political system and exposes the inescapable need for fundamental changes in the way the people and the Government of Trinidad and Tobago do business. Few would disagree that the nation finds itself in a predicament today that was very carefully structured with the help of the population’s own unwillingness to think for itself and preference for allowing leaders to do the thinking. It makes one wonder how the current period will be described later on when others reflect upon the mistakes we made. The time has come for each citizen of Trinidad and Tobago to find or make the time to pause, reflect, understand and reconsider. What has happened? Where are we now? What brought us here and on this path, where are we headed? Our very survival as a nation depends on us willingly accepting that vital “growing pain” of pausing to reflect and reconsider. In doing that we must also steel ourselves with a firm resolve to embrace change where needed. And we have sufficient years of colonial and independent history upon which to reflect.

One of the major revelations of the recent elections is the fact that it was simply not a victory for anyone but rather one of the most resounding defeats for our entire political system. The system itself has experienced a failure and a near breakdown, owing largely to the evident loss of trust among the people of the country coupled with a number of a ‘newly street wise voters’ who have decided that political support of philosophy and ideas is insignificant when one considers the gains of PIP (party in power) support. What we can expect of this and quite likely it has already started to occur, is that more and more of the population will lose sight of needs, replacing them with quick fix desires. Our system is being pulled deeper into a mode of ‘today for today’ and tomorrow will deal with itself. We can expect things to become more reckless later on. Coming out of the last election also was a very clear indication that people have wised up to the fact that unless the party they support controls the Government, they can hardly hope for a fair shake in various development projects. The cost of street-lights and clear drains was a vote for PIP. If you could not pay by that method of exchange then you would literally be left in the dark. Take a hole in the road as further penance. And as the results showed, many decided to withhold the little political currency they controlled perhaps in hope of shaking up the political directorate. But that strategy failed. The People’s National Movement leader was beside himself as he proclaimed unprecedented victory for his party. And the leader of the Opposition pledged to fight harder.

But neither of the leaders cared to admit that the results of not even a 40 percent vote pointed to a very serious decline in the level of support for both parties and politics in general. It points to a heightening in the level of cynicism. The failure to do this reflects poorly on both men as leaders and the results provide evidence of the need for constitution reform. People have convinced themselves almost fully that voting is irrelevant unless they are willing to step aside from their principled support and jump onto the bandwagon of PIP. The Local results also created a fierce atmosphere that bared the preoccupation with the PNM on destroying the Opposition and not merely tactically fighting it, which clearly is not an option. Tact creates the possibility of making people think, destruction simply would create the feeling of, ‘well there is no one else.’ The party in Government refuses to accept that the Opposition represents opposing ideas of a great many people, and rather than busying themselves with studying their views and truly working for the good of the people, they want to stomp on the other side. So, in a situation where half of the population is extremely sensitive, Patrick Manning is telling the support base of the Opposition to come across and be a part of the PNM or you too will be destroyed.

Things were made worse after the callous revival of the view of a “hostile and recalcitrant minority” by Government MP, Fitzgerald Hinds. UNC supporters must either remain just that, or by virtue of joining the PNM, embrace a ‘new’ and ‘progressive’ ideal. And our political system allows men and women to proclaim these things with impunity. But for all of the faults of our political system, the people of this country must shoulder the mass of the blame for allowing us to sink so low before realising that the need for change must not be manipulated by the whims of the Prime Minister, but must rather be influenced by two sobering factors, the good of the state and the good of the people. By 2005, we will arrive at the Government’s mid term and the PNM will have under its belt, the mistaken claim of the Local Election victory. And they will use it as the whip that they will attempt to continue to blister the UNC with. But this blistering could well be, as it is now, in the absence of any genuine claims to policies and programmes that can induce development of the nation. The development of human capital must be the primary goal of any Government driven by a genuine desire for full development. And we have seen nothing of the sort in spite of claims that development is continuing apace. But having never considered what our goals must be in an international context, most of the population is not even aware of the place the nation is at right now. The minority voice of reason that has been mostly ignored in the past must become the pervading influence in this period of reflection. Under that influence, we need to consider all the factors that brought us to this point. The people must consider how many times they resisted political education. And there were many times. They resisted it because of a culture of ‘liking things simple.’

The people must consider how cheaply they surrendered their chances for comfort by blind political support in exchange for dead end relief jobs. The people must consider how they allowed leaders the privilege of re-inventing the roles that votes gave them by adopting the position of ‘do as I say’ and who don’t like it, ‘grin and bear it.’ People need to understand that the nation will not develop until they begin accepting challenges. And the first challenge is to force a new, intelligent, sensitive and progressive kind of leadership based on the dictates of a new constitution that would allow the equity most believe they can never have. As a country, we must crave a new understanding where we pull ourselves up to knowledge rather than wanting it all to be oversimplified for us. It spells a need for a complete overhaul of the way we live and the rules we live by. The election result has also shown our still too strong preoccupation with personalities. We argue so much along those lines primarily because we have placed the highest premium on personalities in politics.

But that has allowed the development of egoistic men and women who have grown to believe that it is their divine right to lead. And then we argue against the result of the efforts we endorsed. Much of our politics is therefore contradictory and that represents the flat tire that we refuse to change in the vehicle that must take us forward. Halfmadeness is actually one of Naipaul’s more generous descriptions of our society. We have not come to the point of being able to think for ourselves. We depend on polls to tell us who will win. We depend on analysts and the media to form our opinions, we depend on foreign agencies to tell us how our private and public sectors are functioning, we condemn propaganda and yet fall prey to it and while we condemn leaders, we cannot articulate our own views because we just don’t know what to say or do. A pause for reflection MUST occur, under conditions that allow people to understand that they are the ones who will cause development or prevent it and how. More than that, they are the ones who can pull the country out of this rut. It is not about waiting for the Government to make the right decisions. The people must accept the education that would allow them to know what the right decisions are. And I dare say that would be the worst fear of any Government: a population that is aware of what it needs, and how to achieve it. It will be a long process but it must start and be sustained in part by the politicians relaxing their foolish stunts for attention and allowing the population to consider the things that can make us a fully made society.


ROGER D RAMCHARITAR
Port-of-Spain

Good work, Justice Elder

THE EDITOR: I am genuinely impressed with all of the reports I have been reading about Justice Pamela Elder. I am glad that we have a very strict female judge who is adamant and passionate about punishing sex offenders. Justice Elder is absolutely right — it is unacceptable to sexually molest children and these crimes must be given a serious sentence.

Incest, rape and sexual molestation of innocent children is rampant in our country and everyone turns a blind eye. In Friday’s papers I read the article “20 years for raping girl, 14” and I was impressed with the sentencing of the crime. However, I then turned a few pages to find “Man guilty of buggering girl, 4.” What a sad world we live in that some people cannot even play with children without losing self control.
We have to do something about all these sick people in our country because anyone who has sexual urges towards children has a mental illness and needs not only punishment for their crimes, but also mental counselling.

I don’t know if our correctional facilities offer that type of counselling, but thank goodness we have at least one judge who cares deeply about this issue and is not afraid to pass some very serious sentences to sex offenders. I just want to tell Justice Elder to keep up the good work — you have a lot of support!


EMILY DICKSON
Port-of-Spain

Mr Panday’s sun is set

THE EDITOR: It is obvious to me that Mr Panday’s political sun has set. Nothing is rising tomorrow from that obstructionist. How does his lack of cooperation with any proposal by the government help the members of his party to portray themselves as an alternate government in readiness? He’ll do nothing to cooperate on crime solutions, even though this wave began on his watch.

He will do nothing to cooperate on the Anti-Kidnapping Bill.
He will do nothing to cooperate with the Caribbean Court of Appeal.
He will do nothing.

My question to the media is, why do the three major papers keep covering his every nonsensical utterance as if he is the voice of God, when he is not even the voice of his own people? The people (the voting public) have spoken, twice. His sun is set. He should bask in the afterglow, go home and shut up. The media can help him to shut up by not covering his constant negative utterances. He is, if he is getting a salary as a parliamentarian, drawing money under false pretenses, and sending an erroneous message to all young people, about what the contents of the public purse should be used for. The media should not become his unpaid public relations instrument.

LINDA EDWARDS
Port-of-Spain