Fallout of random violence

THE EDITOR: On Saturday June 7, my wife, my daughter and I paid a visit to a shopping area we have come to enjoy. Accessible shops, good variety, good prices, good food, are some of the attractions of Valpark Shopping Plaza.

Walking through the lanes at about 3.15 pm we were struck by a sort of hushed, shocked quality — people standing around in small groups staring; a shop we often sauntered through had its doors closed. As we stopped to buy a plant we found out why. Not half an hour earlier, right where we stood, bandits with guns had run through. A chilling scenario went through my mind; that had we gotten there half an hour earlier and encountered these two running men with guns, that if we were in their way of escape; that if a gun had gone off, that my wife or my daughter could have been shot. My world would have ended. Not with a whimper but a bang. It can be that simple.

I could not pull myself out of this dark reverie for hours. And the day after, I read in the paper where my Prime Minister said that “the incident at Movie Towne did not affect the average citizen.” Now I am in a constant manic inner dialogue — if I drive faster to where I’m going, will that save my family? Or do I drive slower? What is the safe time to be anywhere? Perhaps at lunch today in a mall somewhere I shall be at the correct spot where a bullet cuts through air — not aimed specifically at me, of course. And if it were to pass through me at just the right junction I would personally have no more problems but suppose the unspeakable happened? Suppose it happened to my wife as she shops in a grocery or my daughter in her classroom.

Mr Prime Minister, nothing is impossible. For one quiet moment try to find that facility which most humans enjoy — it’s called imagination. Suppose for one moment of blinding illumination that not you, but your dear wife or your beloved sons were accidentally eliminated by random violence; close your eyes and make it happen — that’s how “the average citizen” feels. And the unspeakable happens all the time in our country. We are all living by luck and chance. Please Mr Prime Minister, no more fancy political white washes, no more side-stepping the issue. The “average citizen” wants to see something positive happen that will make us feel safe or at least, safer. It needs to have no stylish name. I do not want to believe, as I do now, metaphysically, a hot piece of metal is already flying through the air awaiting the right day or night to pass through delicate tissue that I love.


DESMOND JUTLA
Maraval

Sorry, Mr Volney

WHEN will the issue of capital punishment in our country be satisfactorily resolved? We now have the farce of judges sentencing convicted murderers to hang but the State seems either reluctant or impotent to remove the barriers which the Law Lords of the Privy Council have placed in the way of carrying out these executions. This ridiculous situation was again highlighted last Friday when Justice Herbert Volney, presiding in the San Fernando First Criminal Assizes, hoped the two men found guilty of murder before him would in fact be hanged because of the “sheer cruelty” with which their victim met his death.

The two young men, Kamal Pooran and Ramzan Asgarali, were found guilty of murdering 62-year-old Rio Claro taxi driver Surujbally “Billy” Mohan whose half-naked body was found hog-tied to a cocoa tree in the Rio Claro forest. He had been strangled. Judge Volney told the convicted men: “Before I impose the mandatory death sentence upon you, I want to express my hope that those who are responsible for carrying out the execution ordered by the Court will take steps to ensure that, having regard to the facts exposed in this trial, of the sheer cruelty of the death of the victim, that the death sentence is in fact carried out on both of you.” At a time when violent crime and cold-blooded murder have become a major concern in TT, we feel sure that a majority of our citizens will fully agree with the feeling and sentiments expressed by Justice Volney, but the embarrassing reality is that the State’s hands are tied with respect to executing the sentence of the Court and the Government has apparently settled for that status quo. The latest shackle imposed by the Law Lords is their 2000 ruling in a Jamaican case which gives convicted murderers the right to be heard by the Mercy Committee and, in the event of an adverse decision, they are entitled to take a motion for judicial review right up to the Privy Council. In effect, the Law Lords have rewritten our country’s constitution by imposing a quasi-judicial function on the Mercy Committee to which convicted killers can now bring attorneys to argue their cases.

In our view, this is totally ridiculous but it is clearly another stratagem by the Law Lords to frustrate the conduct of capital punishment in TT and other countries of the Commonwealth Caribbean. Where previously the Mercy Committee sat quietly and considered whether there were any circumstances in each case that warranted mercy, they must now go through a kind of second trial with their decision susceptible to judicial review which can eventually reach the Law Lords themselves. The length of time that this process could consume would, of course, help to push the date of execution beyond the five-year deadline imposed by the Privy Council itself in the infamous Pratt and Morgan case. So convicted murderers now have this Mercy Committee hearing to add to all the other time consuming strategies, including the filing of constitutional motions, they can use to take advantage of the Pratt and Morgan ruling. Still, the fact is that under the UNC government, with Mr Ramesh Lawrence Maharaj as Attorney General, the State was able to carry out the death sentence imposed on Dole Chadee and eight of his henchmen for the murder of the Baboolal family. All the appeals, the constitutional motions, the petitions to human rights bodies brought by the convicted men were concluded within the space of three years. It was clear that the former AG was not content to allow the abolitionist Law Lords to frustrate the order of our courts and had even devised an amendment of our constitution that would offset all the impediments and constraints they had imposed. Under a PNM Government the situation now seems sadly different. Sorry, Mr Volney.

SAME OLD COLONISING


A spin-off of globalisation, which is adversely affecting the ability of many young Trinidadians and Tobagonians to effectively plan their future, is the growing trend by both the public and private sectors of the tactic of employment on contract for short, specified, or contract labour.

Government Ministries, Education, Housing, Sports and Youth Affairs and what have you, increasingly advertise in the Media for applications for a wide range of jobs, many requiring University degrees or other forms of specialised training. In turn, there are scores of persons employed in the private sector on contract. When the noose of globalisation tightens, and this country, for example becomes part of the soon-to-be Free Trade Area of the Americas, yet more sought after employment opportunities will be positions on contract. Simultaneously, employment opportunities, above the level of those obtaining in duty- free industrial areas, will contract. It is today’s reality in which developed countries, with the United States of America and the more powerful industrial Member States of the European Union out front, seek to dictate terms and conditions of world trade to their advantage.

A not insubstantial number of large corporations in the United States instituted a policy of contract labour years ago as one of the strategies adopted to counter the power of the trade unions, as well as to hold costs down in a highly competitive world. The corporations have for long been assisted by successive US Administrations, which sought to keep wages in check, through an Immigration policy of allocating entry quotas to foreign countries, albeit with a decided preference to those of Europe. Always, the idea has been that US-produced goods, and goods produced by American companies outside of the US, should have the competitive edge. For the past several decades there has been an explosion of developing countries, many of them in the Far East, bent on challenging the US and Europe in the international market place. This has resulted in a contracting of American and European export markets. The USA and Western Europe countered, respectively, in addition to the World Trade Organisation, with the North American Free Trade Area [NAFTA] and the development of the European Union, itself a free trade area.

NAFTA, which embraced the US, Canada and Mexico, saw the relocating and/or the establishing of American industries in Mexico, which capitalised on extremely low cost labour in the Central American country as well as tariff-free entry into the United States of the Mexico-produced US goods. The manufactures could then be sold at more competitive prices than had they been produced in the US. With the introduction of the FTAA in 2005, US-owned Mexican manufactures entering Trinidad and Tobago and the rest of CARICOM tariff-free will be in an even stronger position to challenge Trinidad and Tobago goods, both here and in the CARICOM market. In turn, although West Europe no longer has empires within the continent of Africa, companies set up in the heyday of colonialism are still, for the most part, under the control of British, French and other ‘investors’. They are still in a position to purchase raw materials in many an African country at low prices, export them to their countries, refine them and re-export the finished products to Africa, as well as export them to other areas, at relatively high prices, ensuring the same obscene profits. As Alvin Toffler tells us in his work, The Third Wave [Page 88] published in 1980, the price paid for a commodity would be deliberately kept low. If the raw material or produce had not been sold earlier [on the international market] then the initial price, under the advantageous application of the “Law of the First Price”, held. But the colonisers went further and very often used military might to ‘persuade’ the Africans to accept an absurdly low price.

Trinidadians and Tobagonians, of an earlier generation, would recall that the country’s crude oil was for many decades a victim of the grossly unjust “Law of the First Price”. Indeed, it was not until the Arab dominated Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries [OPEC] instituted a system under which it taxed crude as though it was being sold at a named price, that Third World oil producing nations, in particular, and including Trinidad and Tobago, were able to receive a decent price for their oil. The recent conquering of Iraq and its huge oil reserves by the United States of America and the United Kingdom, will see a downward movement of Trinidad and Tobago and world crude prices. But I have strayed. Again, it was Toffler [The Third Wave], who would stress that it was the metropolitan countries that were the principal beneficiaries of free trade, which incidentally, had been tried by Europe, on and off, for centuries. Toffler said bluntly that despite “much Imperialistic rhetoric about the virtues of free trade and enterprise”, that it was the metropolitan nations which “profited greatly from what was euphemistically called ‘imperfect competition’.” Today, Trinidad and Tobago, as so many other countries, finds itself a prisoner of globalisation. It can neither fight it nor stand aloof. This applies equally to any other CARICOM country. Yet despite, the clear threat posed by globalisation, and I should emphasise, the around-the-corner establishment of the FTAA, the English speaking Caribbean, which should have established the Caribbean Single Market and Economy several years ago still plays the ‘manana’ game. We may have severe reservations about it, but we have to accept the reality of the latest attempt by some of the major powers to ‘re-colonise’ large areas of the world. A unified Caribbean Community, English speaking and otherwise, would have been able to negotiate favourable terms of entry into the FTAA, and would have been in a better bargaining position with the World Trade Organisation, especially had it developed closer links with the two Latin American free trade areas.

Weep for environment

THE EDITOR: June 05, 03, Trinidad and Tobago joins the rest of the world in celebrating World Environmental Day 2003. But what is there to celebrate about the environment?

Each day as I look out my window I am saddened by the degradation of the environment. Everywhere there are signs of deterioration, on our roads, in our houses, the hills, the mountains, the rivers, our immediate surroundings. Everyday we can see the destruction of man’s insensitivity to the environment. The air, the land, the sea, the heavens all polluted, dead fish turning up on our river banks, smog and smoke from motor vehicles, slashing and burning of the hills, chemicals being released into our water courses and into the air, flooding in the rainy season resulting in loss of property, animals and personal belongings.

Our rivers and water courses are clogged and in many cases, people dump garbage indiscriminately, including old stoves, old refrigerators, car tyres, mattresses. Mother Nature must be saddened by this degradation of the environment. Who is responsible for the mess we have found ourselves in? Each and every citizen has a responsibility to take care of the environment which he or she occupies daily. Another form of pollution is noise pollution, and it speaks for itself. So much unnecessary noise in the environment, how sad! As we celebrate, why not do something positive for the environment. I suggest planting a tree or cleaning up your immediate surroundings before the rains come. Trinidad and Tobago, let us all strive for a clean and healthy environment.


KEN SMITH
Woodbrook

Be fair to ‘senior teachers’

THE EDITOR: This is an open letter to the Ministry of Education and to TTUTA concerning the implementation of the post of Senior Teacher. Schools with a registration of under 400 students do not have a Vice Principal. Whenever the principal is absent, the most senior teacher on staff performs the duties of the principal. That person is usually referred to as “the senior teacher.” These duties are voluntarily performed by such teachers.

Now, the Government has created a post of Senior Teacher for such schools, which they intend to bring on stream in September 2003. They want teachers to apply for these posts and be interviewed and selected by the Teaching Service Commission. I suggest that for the introduction of these posts, they appoint the teachers who are currently performing these duties voluntarily. To do otherwise would be unfair and unjust to these teachers and would lead to frustration and possibly disappointment later on. So I am now calling on all such “senior teachers” to request that our union take up that case with the authorities. Let us give them the task of getting the Ministry to agree to guarantee our appointments for the implementation and afterwards, as posts become vacant, they then advertise, interview and select new appointees.


MONA RYAN
San Juan

‘Put pensioners in gas chamber’

THE EDITOR: I shall be grateful if you can insert in your esteemed paper this article on the plight of Government pensioners. With the present cost of living which has increased to an alarming height and the increase in all our utilities, life has become burdensome.

When one considers that our Parliamentarians have increased their pay a hundred fold, the chairmen of the utilities have all been given an increase, some as high as $7,000 a month, and the Prime Minister says there is nothing wrong with such an increase. And yet government pensioners who rendered yeoman service are begging, doing menial jobs to eke out an existence. I retired in 1971 as principal of one of the largest schools with an enrolment of 1,000. My pension today is $1,600 almost the same as ordinary old age pensioners. What a disgrace, dishonour and hardship after my service as a pioneer in education? My advice to the caring and benevolent government is to use the gestapo method of Hitler, put frustrated pensioners in the gas chamber and wipe them out; it would at least be kinder than to have them suffer in their old age.


SAMUEL DOODNATH
ex-School Principal
Penal

Work for abortion fanatics

THE EDITOR: Why is that pro-choice people try to give the impression that it is only the Catholic Church that is against abortion? If one checks with the Inter-Religious Organisation, anyone can come to realise that most religious organisations: Anglicans, Muslims, Seventh Day Adventists, Pentecostals, Evangelicals, etc, all consider abortion a dastardly act against life.

True, the Catholic Church is in the forefront of the opposition to abortion and thank God for that. Ms Denise Johnson in her letter published May 14 boasts that the Parliaments of Colombia and Uruguay, even though their respective Catholic populations are 90 percent and 60 percent, have removed abortion from their criminal laws and suggests that because the Trinidad and Tobago Catholic population is less than 30 percent, our Government should do the same.

History is replete with examples where a small group of very active persons can influence and control whole nations by clandestine manoeuvers, while the silent majority remains silent. It has been said, “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good people to do nothing.” We only have to look at Nazi Germany, Baghdad, Iran, Zimbabwe, etc to see where small interest groups have controlled whole nations by draconian legislation.

My view of what has happened in Colombia and Uruguay is that a small group of pro-choice persons have been successful in having laws changed while the silent majority either did not know what was happening or remained silent. In fact I am certain that if a referendum is held in those countries, and in Trinidad and Tobago, the result will be a resounding no against the decriminalisation of abortion. People of Trinidad and Tobago, we must not remain silent and let only a few fanatics foist on us what they think is right. We must let our government know that abortion kills our babies and that it is a criminal act.


JOHN MACKAY
Federation Park

Try some exercise

THE EDITOR: I do wish we had a Carnival celebration in Trinidad and Tobago every three months. Why you might ask? Well, in preparation for Carnival the old, not so old and the young at heart exercise. The point I am making is that people should exercise continuously in order to prevent the onset of hypertension, diabetes, heart problems and stroke, yes people, stroke.

It seems to me that more and more people in TT are being afflicted with stroke. I am calling on the rich and the poor to find time to walk, in your yard, on the pavement, in front of your home, anywhere. Just walk. Leave the elevators and use the steps. Being unable to walk or use a limb is not easy at all. Editor, Sir, I hope you publish this bit of advice in a manner that will attract your readers, you and your staff. Eating the right food is not all. Just do a bit of exercise. “Try it nuh.”


THOMAS METCAFFE
Pt Cumana

Camera thieves pick ‘Bones’ clean

BRIDGETOWN: Veteran cricket photographer Colin “Bones” Cumberbatch was a picture of disappointment on Sunday after suffering the theft of more than US $20,000 worth of camera equipment at Kensington Oval.

The dreadlocked Cumberbatch, an Antiguan resident who has covered countless cricket matches in Barbados over the last 20 years, lost two Nikon cameras valued at about US $9,000, four lenses worth about US $8,000 and other equipment including a memory card, a charger, a palm reader and flashes. “I feel completely hollowed and depleted. This is the worst experience of my professional life,” Cumberbatch told the Barbados Nation newspaper. “I can’t work and being self-employed, I have to replace the equipment myself. It will be a tremendous financial burden.”

After taking pictures during the first Cable and Wireless One-Day International between West Indies and Sri Lanka on Saturday evening, Cumberbatch left the equipment at the back of the Peter Short Media Centre on the ground floor just outside the control room of television producers Trans World International (TWI). He went up to the third floor of the media centre where he spent about half-hour, but on returning downstairs, he discovered his bag of equipment was missing. Cumberbatch assumed it was safely stored away by TWI, as had been the case in the past. But when he returned to Kensington yesterday morning, he found the bag without its contents.

Cumberbatch, who has covered West Indies tours of England, South Africa, India, Pakistan and Sri Lanka in the past, said the equipment was insured, but the coverage was restricted to Antigua only.In spite of the experience, he still held Barbados in high esteem. “I can’t allow the act of one individual to reflect on the honesty of Barbadian people. It’s the one place that I’ve always felt secure about leaving my equipment around.”

Australia honour 199 living Test cricketers

SYDNEY: The Australian Cricket Board are to honour the country’s 199 living Test cricketers at a special function in Sydney today.

They will each receive a commemorative baggy green cap and an official Test number, recognising each individual’s place in the list of players to have represented Australia. “The 385 players who have worn the baggy green cap have collectively contributed to a sporting tradition that in turn has helped develop our distinctive Australian national culture,” said ACB chief executive James Sutherland. Bill Brown, who made his debut against England at Trent Bridge in 1934, is Australia’s oldest surviving Test player. His commemorative cap will carry the number 150 while Queensland batsman Martin Love will be 385 following his first appearance against England last winter.

“The foundations of the game today and the commercial success that it now enjoys are a direct result of the efforts and achievements of all players who have earned the right to wear the baggy green,” said Tim May, head of the Australian Cricketers Association. “This function represents an ideal opportunity to not only recognise those players who have contributed to Test cricket’s great history, but also to remind us of the depth of such foundations.” Australia recently beat West Indies 3-1 in the Caribbean to confirm their place as the world’s top Test side. Steve Waugh’s team will return to action next month for two home Tests against Bangladesh. It will be the first time Test cricket has been played in the northern Australian cities of Darwin and Cairns.